SHOP OPERATIONS

Etsy’s Customer Service Standards

Etsy scores message replies, on-time shipping, low reviews, and cases. Missing them can reduce search visibility and block Purchase Protection.

Updated November 3, 2026. SellerToolsHQ is an independent publisher and may earn a commission from some tool links.

Quick answer

Answer 80% of first messages within 48 hours. Ship at least 80% of orders on time. Keep low reviews inside the limit for your review count. For cases, shops under 300 orders may have no more than 3 orders refunded from the seller’s account, and shops with 300 or more orders must stay under 1%. Auto-replies count as a first reply. Meeting the standards is also required for Purchase Protection. Repeat misses can suspend selling.

Key takeaways

  • Only the first message in a new thread counts. Spam you report, Etsy-to-you messages, and later replies in the same thread do not.
  • Marking a message unread does not make it new again.
  • On-time shipping follows the processing time on the listing. Tracking is not required for this 80% standard. It is required for Star Seller and Purchase Protection.
  • Under 40 reviews, no more than 4 should be 3 stars or lower. Over 40 reviews, fewer than 10% should be 3 stars or lower.
  • Shops under 300 orders may have no more than 3 orders with cases refunded from the seller’s account. Shops with 300 or more orders must stay under 1%. Orders over $250, orders covered by Purchase Protection, and orders refunded before a case opened do not count. Stats show after 5 sales in the last 3 months.

Four areas, four published numbers

Etsy’s standards article, checked November 3, 2026, lists message response rate, on-time shipping and tracking, average review rating, and case rate. These sit in the Seller Policy. Meeting them is how Etsy says you avoid lower search visibility. Beating them can qualify you for Star Seller. Missing them repeatedly can suspend selling. Purchase Protection also requires that you meet them.

Messages: 80% of first messages in a thread within 48 hours. Later messages in that thread do not count. Neither do spam you report, messages in the From Etsy folder, or messages outside the current review period. An auto-reply counts as the first reply. The setup is in auto-replies.

Shipping: at least 80% of orders ship inside the processing time on the listing. Tracking is a best practice for this standard and is not required to pass it. Star Seller and Purchase Protection still want tracking on eligible orders. Reviews: the low-star caps above. The weighted shop average is a different calculation, in review score.

Case rate: Etsy counts cases where a refund was taken from your Payment account. Shops under 300 orders may have no more than 3 orders with cases refunded from the seller’s account. Shops with 300 or more orders must stay under 1%. Orders over $250, orders covered by Purchase Protection, and orders refunded before a case opened do not count. Stats show after 5 sales in the last 3 months. Reply steps are in how buyer cases work.

Do it in this order

  1. 1. Reply to the first message within 48 hours

    Eighty percent of those first messages is the published bar. An auto-reply counts. A later message in the thread does not reset it.

  2. 2. Ship inside the processing profile

    Eighty percent on time is the shipping bar. Set the profile to a window you can keep. See processing profiles.

  3. 3. Watch 3-star and lower reviews

    Four or fewer if you have under 40 reviews. Under 10% if you have more than 40.

  4. 4. Stay inside the case-rate cap

    Shops under 300 orders may have no more than 3 orders with cases refunded from the seller’s account. Shops with 300 or more orders must stay under 1%. Orders over $250, orders covered by Purchase Protection, and orders refunded before a case opened do not count.

  5. 5. Do not confuse this with Star Seller

    The standards are the floor. Star Seller is a higher badge and still wants tracking.

Frequently asked questions

What is Etsy’s message response standard?

Respond to 80% of first messages in a thread within 48 hours. Auto-replies count. Later messages in the same thread, reported spam, and Etsy account messages do not.

What is the on-time shipping standard?

At least 80% of orders shipped within the processing time you set. Tracking is not required for this particular standard.

How many low reviews can I have?

If you have fewer than 40 reviews, no more than 4 should be 3 stars or lower. If you have more than 40, less than 10% should be 3 stars or lower.

What is Etsy’s case rate standard?

Shops under 300 orders may have no more than 3 orders with cases refunded from the seller’s account. Shops with 300 or more orders must stay under 1%. Orders over $250, orders covered by Purchase Protection, and orders refunded before a case opened do not count. Stats show after 5 sales in the last 3 months.

What happens if I miss the standards?

Etsy says search visibility can be lower, Purchase Protection requires that you meet the standards, and repeated violations can suspend selling.

Related on SellerToolsHQ

Sources checked November 3, 2026

Etsy, eBay, Amazon, and tool vendors can change screens and prices. Use the linked page if this article and your account disagree.