ORDERS

How to Handle an Etsy Case from a Buyer

See when a buyer can open an Etsy case, where to reply, and what Etsy Purchase Protection covers up to $250.

Updated November 3, 2026. SellerToolsHQ is an independent publisher and may earn a commission from some tool links.

Quick answer

A case is a formal report that the order did not arrive, arrived damaged, did not match the listing, or arrived at least 7 days after the latest estimated delivery date. Reply in Shop Manager, Help, Cases. Keep every comment in the case log. If the order qualifies for Purchase Protection, Etsy can refund the buyer and cover up to $250.

Key takeaways

  • The latest estimated delivery date must have passed, and the buyer must have contacted you at least 48 hours earlier. A non-delivery case also waits 7 or more days after that delivery date. The buyer then has 30 days to open the case.
  • Work in the case log. You can comment, attach images, and sometimes refund or update shipping from that page.
  • A full Etsy Payments refund, delivered tracking on a non-delivery case, or the buyer closing the case can close it.
  • Etsy can refund the buyer and take the uncovered amount from your payment account.
  • Cases opened before May 7, 2026 use the Purchase Protection policy that was in effect then.

The only reasons Etsy lists

Etsy’s case article, checked November 3, 2026, limits buyer cases to non-delivery, an item that was not as described, damage, and arrival 7 or more days after the maximum estimated delivery date from checkout. Not every case counts against the shop if you are meeting the customer service standard. The standard itself is in the customer service standards guide.

For most cases, Etsy uses the shipping status and Purchase Protection eligibility. If it needs more, you get a note in the case log and an email. You have to answer. When the case closes, both of you get an email.

Purchase Protection is not a guarantee

If the order is eligible, the buyer gets a full refund. Etsy covers up to $250, or the converted amount in your currency, and charges you the rest. You do not send that refund yourself. Etsy says the program is not insurance, a warranty, or a guarantee, and that it decides whether a transaction qualifies. It can also change or stop the program, and it can resolve a case for you, including a refund taken from your payment account.

Eligibility details, including the 48-hour help-request reply and tracking, are in Purchase Protection for sellers. Proof of shipping for a non-delivery case is tracking to the address on the receipt or the address you agreed in Messages. For damage or a not-as-described claim, comment in the log, acknowledge the problem, and say what you can do. If you disagree with a closed “different than described” or “arrived damaged” outcome, Etsy says to contact them about that specific result. It says it generally will not reopen a never-received or 7-days-late outcome, because the tracking record is already the evidence.

A chargeback is a different dispute

A bank, card company, or PayPal dispute is a chargeback, not an Etsy case. Etsy cannot refund an order after a chargeback is filed, because that could pay the buyer twice. Use the chargeback guide if the email is from that process. A refund you issue yourself is also separate: how to refund an order.

Do it in this order

  1. 1. Open the case log

    Shop Manager, Help, Cases, Cases reported about your shop, then the case ID.

  2. 2. Put every fact in the log

    Use Add Your Comment. Attach photos with Attach Image. Do not leave the only copy of the story in Messages.

  3. 3. Add tracking if the issue is delivery

    Etsy wants a valid tracking number to the receipt address. Update shipping from the case if that control is there.

  4. 4. Refund only when you mean to

    A full Etsy Payments refund can close the case. A chargeback already in progress disables the Etsy refund.

  5. 5. Answer Etsy if they ask

    If the log or email asks for more information, respond. After the case closes, you and the buyer get an email.

Frequently asked questions

When can a buyer open an Etsy case?

The maximum estimated delivery date must have passed, and at least 48 hours must have passed since the buyer contacted you. A non-delivery case also requires 7 or more days after that delivery date. The buyer then has 30 days to open it.

Where do I reply to an Etsy case?

Shop Manager, Help, Cases. Use the case log. Etsy says to keep the case information there, and you can attach images.

Will a case always cost me the refund?

No. If the order qualifies for Purchase Protection, Etsy covers up to $250 of the refund, or the local-currency equivalent, and you pay only the remainder. Etsy decides eligibility.

What closes a case automatically?

Etsy lists a full refund through Etsy Payments, a non-delivery case with no tracking or with tracking that shows delivery to the receipt address, and the buyer closing the case.

Related on SellerToolsHQ

Sources checked November 3, 2026

Etsy, eBay, Amazon, and tool vendors can change screens and prices. Use the linked page if this article and your account disagree.