REVIEWS

How to Respond to an Etsy Review

Message the buyer first. A public Etsy response can be posted once, within 100 days of the buyer’s last edit, and it locks their review.

Updated November 3, 2026. SellerToolsHQ is an independent publisher and may earn a commission from some tool links.

Quick answer

Start in Messages on the order. A public response is optional, allowed once, and must be posted within 100 days of the buyer’s last edit. You can delete that public response later, but you cannot edit it. After you post it, the buyer cannot edit their review even if you delete your reply.

Key takeaways

  • A private message can lead the buyer to edit their review. A public reply removes that option.
  • Shoppers see the public reply on the listing reviews and the shop reviews page.
  • Do not include tracking numbers, external links, or private information. Etsy removes responses that break the review policy.
  • Write it for the next shopper, not only for the reviewer. One response, no second chance to reword it.
  • The path is Sales Channels, your shop, Reviews, Post a public response.

Private first

Etsy’s negative-review article, checked November 3, 2026, says the best first move is Messages. From the order, use the mail icon, acknowledge the problem, and offer a real fix if you know what went wrong. If you do not, ask what happened and stay courteous. A fast private reply can be enough for the buyer to edit the review. The score those stars feed is explained in how the Etsy review score works.

The public reply is permanent in one direction

You have 100 days from the date the buyer last edited the review. You can respond once. Shoppers see it. You may delete it later, but you cannot edit it or add another. Posting it, even if you then delete it, stops the buyer from editing their original review or rating. They also cannot reply to your reply.

Etsy’s writing rules: short, professional, about the product and what you changed, not about the reviewer. Do not include a tracking number, an external link, or private information. Responses that break the review policy are removed. Open the form from Shop Manager, the shop name under Sales Channels, Reviews, Post a public response.

Do it in this order

  1. 1. Message the buyer from the order

    Shop Manager, Orders, the mail icon. Offer a fix or ask what happened before you write in public.

  2. 2. Decide if future shoppers need a reply

    If the private thread solved it, you can stop. A public reply is for the record other people will read.

  3. 3. Post once, inside 100 days

    Sales Channels, your shop, Reviews, Post a public response. You cannot edit it afterward.

  4. 4. Leave out tracking, links, and private details

    Etsy removes responses that include those.

  5. 5. Delete only if you are willing to lose the reply

    Deleting does not let the buyer edit their review again, and it does not let you write a second response.

Frequently asked questions

How long do I have to respond to an Etsy review?

100 days from the date the buyer last edited the review. You can post one public response.

Can I edit an Etsy review response?

No. You can delete it. You cannot edit it or post another one. After you post, the buyer cannot edit their review either, even if you delete your response.

Should I reply in public or in Messages?

Etsy says to message the buyer first. A public reply is for when you want other shoppers to see how you handled the issue.

What gets a public response removed?

Etsy says not to include tracking numbers, external links, or private information, and to follow the review policy. Responses that do not are removed.

Related on SellerToolsHQ

Sources checked November 3, 2026

Etsy, eBay, Amazon, and tool vendors can change screens and prices. Use the linked page if this article and your account disagree.